NMC 41 - IMA Leadership View


Dr K K Aggarwal    17 December 2017

  • The Union cabinet effectively ended the era of Medical Council of India yesterday. The citadel of modern medicine which initiated every young man and woman to the noble profession to alleviate the pain and suffering will cease to exist.
  • The glorious era of MCI which produced doctors of international calibre to serve the humankind as global doctors will come to an end. It will be replaced by a near total Government department called National Medical Commission.
  • IMA has been opposing NMC in its present form.
  • Devoid of federal character this non-representative half non-medical body will be a poor substitute for the MCI.
  • NMC will not represent the medical profession of India.

·       Anywhere in the world, medical profession is bestowed with reasonable autonomy. Patient care and Patient safety are the main benefits of such autonomy. 

·       Regulators need to have autonomy and be independent of the administrators.  The National Medical Commission will be a regulator appointed by the administrators under their direct control.      

·       It abolishes Medical Council of India and along with possibly the section 15 of IMC Act which says that the basic qualification to practise modern medicine is MBBS.

·       It takes away the voting right of every doctor in India to elect their medical council. Medical council of India is a representative body of the medical profession in India.  Any registered medical practitioner in the country can contest the election and every qualified doctor can vote. Abolishing a democratic institution and replacing it by a body in which majority are nominated by the Government is certainly a retrograde step.

·       It allows the private medical colleges to charge at free will nullifying whatever solace NEET brought. The Government can fix the fee for only 40 percent of the seats in private medical colleges.

·       Instituting a Medical Licentiate exam after qualifying in final MBBS exam is an injustice. It is highly insensitive to the plight of medical students who even otherwise must undergo a long and tortuous academic career chequered with highly competitive exams.

·       The federal character of MCI is not found in NMC. All the state Governments have representation in MCI. Only 5 states in rotation will have representation in NMC. It will take two decades for a state to re-enter NMC.

·        All universities teaching medicine are members of MCI. This has been abolished in NMC.

·       All state medical councils which are sovereign bodies constituted by state legislatures have been made subservient to NMC striking a blow to the federal nature of the nation.

·       Professional organisations like IMA are registered under Societies Act.  In no way their independence and freedom of action could be subjected to Government control. In fact, they remain the only whistle blowers, being the voice of voiceless in the issues of Health.  Such corrective forces are part and parcel of the democratic forces in the country. NMC has been vested with powers to control all professional bodies.

·       IMA representative is in DNB board but not in NMC

·       It inducts non-medical people into the highest body of medical governance changing its perspective and character for ever.

·       It introduces schedule IV to allow AYUSH graduates to get registration in Modern Medicine.

·       It opens the floodgates of PG seats in modern medicine to AYUSH graduates in future by providing registration to them in schedule IV.

·       It directly affects Patient Care and Patient Safety by allowing graduates of other systems to practise modern medicine.

·       This is not the first time that the Government has made such a move. In 2005, the then Union health minister, Dr Anbumani Ramadoss, tried unsuccessfully to bring in a legislation to dissolve the MCI and set up another council under the control of the Health Ministry. The parliamentary standing committee rejected it because any regulatory body should be devoid of Government control or else it would lose its independent regulatory mechanism. It is pertinent to note that in its exhaustive report the standing committee took exception to the attempt by the Government of India to centralize the powers with itself and reduce a Body of Experts created for a distinct purpose by a Parliamentary enactment into a Department working under the Government of India.

IMA appeals to the Prime Minister to recall the Bill and rectify these anomalies. The Parliament has a larger role to protect the interest of the medical profession of the country. The welfare and the independence of the profession is linked to the welfare of the people.

Dr K K Aggarwal- National President, IMA                                                                                   

Dr Ravi Wankhedkar- National President Elect

Dr RN Tandon - Hony. Secretary General IMA

Dr R V Asokan - Chairman Action Committee

To comment on this article,
create a free account.

Sign Up to instantly get access to 10000+ Articles & 1000+ Cases

Already registered?

Login Now

Most Popular Articles

News and Updates

eMediNexus provides latest updates on medical news, medical case studies from India. In-depth medical case studies and research designed for doctors and healthcare professionals.